Over 40 US state attorneys general ask CFTC to withdraw sports event contract rule

20 November 2026 at 6:05am UTC-5
Email, LinkedIn, and more

Attorneys general from at least 43 US states and the District of Columbia have urged the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) to withdraw a proposed rule classifying sports event contracts as swaps.

The bipartisan coalition submitted a formal comment on 18 November. It was co-led by Ohio Attorney General Andy Wilson and his counterparts in Kentucky, Maryland, Nevada, New Jersey, New York, Tennessee and Utah, and joined by 35 other states and the District of Columbia.

Article continues below ad

“A sports bet isn’t a derivative just because the CFTC says so,” noted Wilson.

The attorneys general point to federal appellate decisions that have rejected the CFTC’s claimed authority over sports betting. They also argue the agency lacks the quorum needed to adopt the rule, as it currently has only one commissioner serving.

The letter warns that the proposal could push traditional sportsbooks to reorganize as prediction markets to sidestep state gambling laws, and help platforms avoid licensing requirements, age restrictions and problem-gambling protections.

Article continues below ad
GLI email

The coalition is urging the CFTC to withdraw the rule and clarify that sports-betting contracts are not financial swaps.

The CFTC proposed the rule in October, seeking to further define swaps to include event contracts based on sports, politics, cultural events and weather.

The comment follows a July effort in which Ohio co-led a bipartisan coalition of 44 attorneys general urging the CFTC to recognize states’ authority over sports-related prediction markets.

Article continues below ad
PayNearMe

Prediction market platform Kalshi is also facing lawsuits in several states, including Utah and Arkansas, while the CFTC recently sued Louisiana over a state court order blocking prediction markets.

Crypto exchange Coinbase has already come out in support of the swap classification by the CFTC.

CiG Insignia
Locations:
Verticals:
Sectors:

Dig Deeper

The Backstory

States push back as CFTC seeks a broader lane

The fight over sports-related prediction markets has moved from a regulatory dispute into a broad federalism clash, with state attorneys general, gaming regulators, tribal interests and market operators all trying to shape where the legal line is drawn. At issue is whether contracts tied to sports outcomes are financial derivatives under federal commodities law or gambling products subject to state licensing, consumer protection and enforcement regimes.

The current challenge from 43 state attorneys general and the District of Columbia follows months of escalating pressure on the Commodity Futures Trading Commission, which has sought to clarify that certain event contracts, including those tied to sports, fall within its authority. States argue that view would allow prediction market platforms to bypass the framework that has governed legal sports betting since the Supreme Court opened the door to state-by-state regulation in 2018.

The dispute carries practical consequences. If the CFTC position holds, platforms could offer sports event contracts nationwide under federal oversight, potentially outside state gambling rules covering licensing, minimum age requirements, responsible gambling obligations, tax collection and market access. If states prevail, platforms such as Kalshi would face a fragmented regulatory map similar to sportsbooks, with each jurisdiction deciding whether and how sports-related products can operate.

Rulemaking turned a court fight into a national test

The CFTC’s October rulemaking efforts gave the conflict a sharper legal and political focus. The agency issued a proposal stating that the definition of “swap” should include event contracts tied to sports, politics, cultural events and weather. At the same time, it moved to exclude casino-style gambling products, including sportsbook wagers and casino games, from that definition.

That dual approach immediately drew scrutiny because it attempted to separate sports event contracts from sportsbook wagers even when both products may allow users to take positions on the same game outcome. The agency said event contracts are financial instruments within its exclusive jurisdiction. Opponents said the distinction was formal rather than substantive, particularly where retail customers use the products in ways that resemble sports betting.

The rules later advanced when the CFTC submitted two prediction market proposals to the White House for review. One would expand the treatment of event contracts under the Commodity Exchange Act, while the other, structured as an interim final rule, would exclude casino-style gaming products from the swap definition. The submission elevated the matter beyond agency interpretation and put the White House review process at the center of a dispute with major implications for both financial markets and gambling policy.

The CFTC’s effort also came as legal momentum was not uniformly favoring prediction market operators. The 6th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals rejected Kalshi’s argument that its sports event contracts were swaps governed exclusively by federal law, allowing Ohio and Tennessee to enforce their gambling regulations. That ruling strengthened the states’ position and helped explain why attorneys general have pressed the agency to withdraw or narrow its rulemaking.

Nevada and gaming regulators reject the distinction

Gaming regulators have been among the most forceful critics of the CFTC’s position because they view the debate as an effort to relabel betting activity. Nevada, which has one of the most developed gambling regulatory systems in the country, has treated prediction markets as a direct challenge to state authority over wagering.

Nevada Gaming Control Board Chairman Mike Dreitzer said the agency’s proposal was not surprising, according to coverage of his response to the CFTC’s reinforcement of sports contract oversight. He described the distinction between a small sportsbook wager and a similarly sized sports event contract as untenable, arguing that the mechanics do not change the underlying character of the activity.

That critique goes to the heart of the states’ case. Prediction market operators emphasize that their products are exchange-based contracts, often with peer-to-peer pricing and the ability to enter and exit positions. Regulators counter that those features are not unique enough to remove sports outcome products from gambling oversight. They point to cash-out functions already common in online sports betting and to other gaming verticals, such as poker or horse racing, where peer-to-peer elements do not erase gambling classifications.

The Nevada view has influenced the broader political debate because it frames the CFTC’s position as a threat to established gaming safeguards rather than a narrow financial market clarification. State officials have warned that if sports outcome contracts are treated as federally regulated derivatives, licensed sportsbooks could seek to reorganize or offer similar products through prediction market structures, undermining years of state-by-state regulatory development.

Kalshi’s political strategy underscores the stakes

Prediction market companies have not relied solely on litigation. Kalshi and Polymarket have increased lobbying and campaign efforts as they seek to preserve access to nationwide markets and prevent state gambling regulators from asserting control. Kalshi has been the largest spender among the platforms, according to filings described in reports on its lobbying efforts against state regulation.

The company reportedly hired lobbyists in 41 states, concentrated efforts in major markets such as California and New York and contributed to attorney general and governor associations for both parties. The strategy reflects where the pressure is coming from: attorneys general have led many of the state challenges, and governors and state agencies will play a central role in determining how aggressively jurisdictions respond to sports-related contracts.

Kalshi’s argument is straightforward. If contracts are listed on a CFTC-regulated exchange and fall under federal commodities law, states cannot impose gambling laws that conflict with that federal regime. That position would give federally regulated platforms a national path that traditional sportsbooks do not have. It also would allow prediction markets to scale rapidly in states that have not authorized online sports betting or that limit market access to licensed operators.

States see the same point from the opposite direction. They argue the model would weaken state police powers and consumer protections by letting platforms compete with licensed sportsbooks without the same tax, compliance and responsible gambling burdens. That concern explains why the latest attorneys general letter drew support across party lines and from states with very different gambling policies.

Tribal and crypto debates widen the conflict

The dispute over sports event contracts has also intersected with broader federal debates about digital assets, commodities oversight and tribal sovereignty. Tribal gaming interests have warned that federal legislation or agency action could unintentionally create a pathway for prediction market platforms to enter gaming markets without respecting tribal compacts or the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act.

Those concerns surfaced in the debate over the CLARITY Act, a crypto market structure bill. A bipartisan group of 17 attorneys general and the Indian Gaming Association urged senators to reject a revised version of the legislation, saying it did not sufficiently preserve state enforcement powers or tribal gaming sovereignty. Although the bill was aimed at digital asset regulation, gaming stakeholders viewed it through the lens of prediction markets and the risk that federal commodities language could preempt state and tribal authority.

The Indian Gaming Association has argued that any federal framework must expressly protect tribal sovereignty and existing gaming law. The American Gaming Association and other industry groups have raised similar concerns about sports event contracts, warning that financial regulation should not become a backdoor route into regulated gambling markets.

This broader coalition matters because it expands the conflict beyond one company or one rule. State attorneys general are focused on enforcement authority. Gaming regulators are focused on licensing and consumer protection. Tribal groups are focused on sovereignty and compact rights. Licensed operators are focused on competitive parity. Together, those interests create a formidable political challenge for the CFTC as it seeks to finalize rules.

A likely path toward higher courts

The legal uncertainty is unlikely to end with the current comment process. The CFTC’s proposed rules, if finalized, are likely to trigger further litigation over the scope of the Commodity Exchange Act, the meaning of event contracts and the extent to which federal commodities oversight preempts state gambling laws.

Industry observers have increasingly treated the issue as one that could reach the Supreme Court. Inside Asian Gaming’s sister publication CDC Gaming has reported that the CFTC is seeking to confirm its authority over prediction markets before the question escalates further, in an article noting the agency’s proposed rules to define sports event contracts as swaps: CFTC proposes rules to confirm prediction market authority.

Until the courts or Congress settle the matter, platforms will face a volatile operating environment. State enforcement actions can limit access in key markets, while favorable federal rulemaking could strengthen the industry’s claim to national reach. For consumers, the outcome will determine whether sports outcome products are treated as investment-like contracts or as gambling products with the protections and restrictions that state systems impose.

The latest attorneys general letter therefore is more than a procedural objection to an agency proposal. It is part of a coordinated effort to prevent a federal regulator from reshaping the sports betting market through commodities law. The CFTC’s next steps will determine whether that fight remains a rulemaking battle or becomes the next major test of who controls gambling in the U.S.