Coinbase “strongly supports” CFTC proposal to include event contracts in “swap” definition
Cryptocurrency exchange Coinbase has submitted a comment letter to the US Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) backing the regulator’s proposal to expressly include event contracts in its definition of “swap.”
In the 18 November letter, signed by Director of Regulatory Policy Julia Hueckel and Director and Associate General Counsel David Shafer, the group noted that “Coinbase strongly supports the Proposal and encourages its swift adoption.”
Coinbase highlighted that its futures commission merchant, Coinbase Financial Markets, offers “customers nationwide access to event contracts listed on a CFTC-registered exchange,” and that it recently registered Coinbase Clearing LLC as a derivatives clearing organization (DCO).
The group supported the proposal’s use of “sports-, politics-, cultural-, and weather-related event contracts” as examples, while asking the CFTC to keep the list non-exhaustive to allow for future contracts tied to “digital-asset and blockchain events, or technology and scientific milestones.”
The exchange furthered that state enforcement actions and conflicting court rulings “create real uncertainty for exchanges, intermediaries, customers, and courts.”
Coinbase also distinguished exchange-traded event contracts from sportsbooks, noting that “Traditional sportsbooks and casinos generally stand on the other side of a customer’s wager.” The group filed separate comments the same day supporting the CFTC’s Interim Final Rule excluding casino-style gambling products from the “swap” definition.
Coinbase has faced state action over its prediction markets, including a lawsuit from the New York Attorney General and a civil enforcement action from Nevada regulators, while the company sued Michigan, Illinois and Connecticut over their attempts to regulate the markets.
Dig Deeper
The Backstory
A federal line-drawing exercise
Coinbase’s support for the Commodity Futures Trading Commission’s proposal lands at a pivotal moment for prediction markets, sports betting regulators and financial firms trying to define a fast-growing product category before courts do it for them. The CFTC is seeking to make explicit that event contracts, including those tied to sports, politics, culture and weather, can fall within the Commodity Exchange Act as swaps. Coinbase’s letter is therefore not just a comment on technical rulemaking. It is part of a broader campaign by market operators to secure federal oversight and limit the reach of state gambling authorities.
The debate accelerated after the CFTC in October issued a proposal saying the swap definition should include event contracts, including sports contracts, while separately adopting an interim final rule excluding casino-style gambling products, including sportsbook wagers and casino games, from that same definition. That paired approach was designed to separate federally regulated derivatives from traditional betting products. It also gave companies such as Coinbase, Kalshi and others a regulatory framework to argue that sports-linked contracts are not simply sports bets under another name.
Why the CFTC moved before the courts
The agency’s timing reflected mounting litigation risk. Before the October notices were published, the CFTC had submitted two prediction market rules to the White House for review, a procedural step that signaled the regulator wanted to harden its position before the dispute reached higher courts. One rule would expand the swap definition to include event contracts. The other would exclude casino-style gambling products from that definition. Together, they attempted to answer the central question dividing regulators: whether a contract on a future event is a federally regulated financial instrument or a state-regulated wager.
The stakes are high because the answer determines who controls access, licensing, taxation and consumer protection standards. If sports-event contracts are swaps, CFTC-registered exchanges and intermediaries could offer them nationally under federal law, with state gambling regulators largely preempted. If they are sports wagers, operators would need state-by-state approvals, gaming licenses and compliance systems that mirror the legal sports betting market built after the Supreme Court struck down the federal sports betting ban in 2018.
That uncertainty has already produced conflicting outcomes. The 6th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that Ohio and Tennessee could enforce gambling regulations against Kalshi, rejecting the company’s argument that sports-event contracts were federally governed swaps. Other courts have appeared more receptive to arguments that the Commodity Exchange Act gives the CFTC exclusive jurisdiction over certain contracts. The agency’s rulemaking is an attempt to reduce that patchwork before it becomes entrenched.
States push back on a national market
State officials have treated prediction markets as a direct challenge to their sports betting regimes. New York Attorney General Letitia James filed lawsuits against Coinbase Financial Markets and Gemini Titan, alleging their event-based prediction markets amount to illegal gambling. The complaints, detailed in New York’s lawsuits against Coinbase and Gemini Titan, accused the platforms of offering markets on political, economic and sports events without state gaming licenses. The attorney general also argued that the companies were avoiding taxes and rules imposed on licensed casinos and mobile sportsbook operators.
Coinbase has framed the matter differently, saying the products are offered through CFTC-regulated structures and should be governed federally. That position mirrors Kalshi’s litigation strategy and the broader industry argument that exchange-traded contracts differ from sportsbook wagers because they are centrally cleared, trade between market participants and do not require the platform to take the other side of the customer’s bet. Coinbase’s latest comment letter leans on that distinction, presenting prediction markets as part of the derivatives ecosystem rather than the gambling industry.
States see a different competitive reality. If federally registered entities can offer sports-linked contracts without state gaming licenses, licensed sportsbooks could face competitors that do not pay the same taxes, meet the same responsible gambling requirements or operate within the same market-access rules. That has drawn opposition not only from attorneys general and regulators but also from tribal gaming groups, which have argued that federally sanctioned sports-event contracts could undermine compacts and exclusivity arrangements negotiated with states.
Kalshi’s cases set the market tone
Kalshi has become the central test case because its sports-event contracts forced courts and regulators to confront the boundary between derivatives and gambling. In New Jersey, a dispute over whether Kalshi could continue offering sports wagers prompted analysts to assess the implications for established sportsbook operators. A Jefferies note covered in an analysis of the New Jersey trial’s effect on DraftKings and FanDuel concluded that a clear ruling could help incumbents even if Kalshi prevailed in part, because uncertainty is often worse for public companies than a defined competitive framework.
The New Jersey arguments showed why the issue is difficult. Kalshi maintained that sports contracts can have commercial consequence and therefore fit within the legal concept of swaps. State regulators countered that the contracts function like sports bets and should not escape gaming law through financial terminology. Judges appeared open to the idea that some sports events could fall within a broad swaps definition, while also questioning whether player prop-style offerings could meet the same standard. That potential distinction remains important because it could shape the scope of any future market, even if federal jurisdiction is recognized.
For DraftKings, FanDuel and other licensed sportsbooks, the outcome is strategic. A broad federal pathway for sports-event contracts could create a national competitor operating outside the state licensing model. A narrower ruling, or CFTC rule, could still allow prediction markets but limit them to products with clearer financial or commercial characteristics. Coinbase’s support for a non-exhaustive list of permissible event contracts suggests the industry wants flexibility to develop beyond politics and sports, including products tied to digital assets, blockchain events and technology milestones.
Financial firms move toward prediction markets
Even as litigation continues, financial services companies are building infrastructure for a larger event-contract market. Clearing Company, a San Francisco firm, has applied to become a CFTC-regulated derivatives clearing organization with plans to launch prediction-market clearing services. The company has said it wants to build a clearinghouse tailored to prediction markets rather than a consumer-facing betting app, underscoring how the sector is being treated by some firms as market plumbing, not entertainment.
That filing followed signs of growing institutional interest, including trading firm Jump Trading creating markets on sports-event contracts offered by Kalshi. Coinbase has also expanded its role by operating Coinbase Financial Markets and registering Coinbase Clearing LLC as a derivatives clearing organization. These moves matter because clearing, custody and exchange access are central to the CFTC’s argument that event contracts are financial instruments subject to federal market regulation.
The emerging structure also gives the CFTC a stronger practical case for jurisdiction. If products trade on registered exchanges, clear through regulated clearing organizations and are intermediated by federally supervised entities, the agency can argue they resemble derivatives markets more than sportsbooks. State regulators, however, are likely to focus on consumer experience: users making yes-or-no predictions on games, teams or athletes may look functionally similar to bettors regardless of the back-end structure.
The next fight is over definitions
The CFTC’s paired rules aim to settle that tension by defining what is inside the swaps regime and what remains outside it. The agency says casino-style gambling products and sportsbook wagers are not derivatives, while event contracts on sports and other outcomes may be. That distinction is legally significant but operationally delicate. If drafted too broadly, it could allow financial exchanges to replicate much of the sportsbook market. If drafted too narrowly, it could weaken the prediction-market model the CFTC says Congress placed under its authority.
Coinbase’s comment letter reflects that balance. The company supports clarity but wants examples to remain non-exhaustive so markets can evolve. It also emphasizes conflict among state enforcement actions and court rulings, arguing that operators, intermediaries and customers need a single federal standard. For the CFTC, the comments create a record supporting the agency’s rulemaking. For states, they sharpen the question of whether federal derivatives law is being used to bypass gambling law.
The result will affect more than one exchange or lawsuit. It could determine whether prediction markets become a federally scaled asset class, a state-by-state gaming product or a hybrid constrained by product type. Until courts and regulators converge, companies will keep racing to shape the definitions that decide who can offer these markets, where they can operate and under which rulebook they must compete.








