CFTC sues Louisiana over court order blocking prediction markets
The US Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) and the US Department of Justice have sued Louisiana to stop the state from enforcing a court order that bars prediction market companies from offering event contracts there.
The lawsuit was filed on 13 November in the US District Court for the Eastern District of Louisiana. It followed a temporary restraining order secured a day earlier by Louisiana Attorney General Liz Murrill against 31 entities linked to prediction market and trading platforms.
Murrill argued that the event contracts offered by prediction market companies constitute gambling and require a state gaming license. Judge Jeffrey Johnson of the 21st Judicial District Court in Tangipahoa Parish granted the order without hearing from the companies involved.
The order bars the companies from offering, accepting or facilitating event contracts in Louisiana without a state license, and it covers contracts linked to sports, elections and awards. It also requires operators to block access for people located in the state.
Among those named are Kalshi, Polymarket US, Robinhood, Coinbase, Crypto.com, Gemini, Interactive Brokers’ ForecastEx, IG Group, Novig, Underdog and ProphetX.
The CFTC is responsible for regulating derivatives markets, and the federal government has argued that event contracts traded on CFTC-regulated markets fall under the Commodity Exchange Act and not state gambling laws.
CFTC Chairman Michael Selig called Louisiana’s lawsuit “naked lawfare and a cynical political stunt,” adding that “event contracts have traded openly in Louisiana for years.” In its complaint, the CFTC argued that immediate relief is needed to “preserve the status quo” while the federal case proceeds.
The CFTC said Louisiana is the 12th state it has sued over the issue. It sued Arkansas, its 11th, last week, and in October sued the state of Utah and its attorney general following the state’s lawsuit against prediction market platform Kalshi.
The temporary restraining order lasts for 10 days unless extended, and a hearing in the state case is set for 30 November.
Dig Deeper
The Backstory
Federal preemption fight reaches Louisiana
The Commodity Futures Trading Commission’s lawsuit against Louisiana marks another escalation in a national fight over who controls prediction markets: federal derivatives regulators or state gambling authorities. Louisiana’s attorney general secured a temporary restraining order in state court against dozens of platforms tied to event contracts, arguing the products amount to gambling and require state gaming licenses. The CFTC and the Justice Department responded in federal court, saying Louisiana’s order intrudes on federally regulated markets governed by the Commodity Exchange Act.
The case follows a pattern that has hardened through 2025. States have increasingly treated sports, election and entertainment event contracts as unauthorized wagering when offered to residents without gaming licenses. The CFTC, under Chairman Michael Selig, has responded by asserting that event contracts traded on CFTC-regulated exchanges are financial instruments, not gambling products subject to state-by-state approval. That conflict has moved from regulatory letters and state enforcement threats into fast-moving litigation across multiple jurisdictions.
Louisiana’s order is notable for its breadth. It names well-known financial and crypto platforms, prediction market operators and sports-adjacent companies, including Kalshi, Polymarket US, Robinhood, Coinbase, Crypto.com, Gemini, ForecastEx, Novig, Underdog and ProphetX. It also requires geoblocking for people in the state. For the CFTC, allowing one state court order to force those companies out of a federally supervised market could invite similar orders elsewhere, fragmenting what the agency says should be a national marketplace.
A state already leaning into gambling enforcement
Louisiana’s move against prediction markets did not come in isolation. State gaming officials have spent recent months presenting a tougher posture toward companies they view as operating outside Louisiana’s regulated gambling system. The Louisiana Gaming Control Board, working with the attorney general’s office and state police gaming enforcement, issued more than 40 cease-and-desist letters to offshore and sweepstakes-style operators accused of targeting Louisiana customers without approval.
That campaign included a formal order against Harp Media, the company also known as Bovada, requiring it to stop offering illegal gambling services in the state. The board framed the effort as part of its statutory obligation to protect the public, preserve market integrity and prevent unlawful operators from undermining licensed gaming businesses. The crackdown, detailed in Louisiana’s enforcement campaign against illegal sweepstakes casinos, helps explain why state officials may see prediction markets through the same lens: as online products that resemble betting, reach local consumers and operate beyond the licensing structure.
The distinction matters because Louisiana has a regulated sports betting market and a consumer-protection framework tied to licensed casinos and approved mobile operators. If event contracts are classified as derivatives, state gaming regulators lose significant leverage over age controls, responsible gambling standards, taxation and suitability reviews. If they are gambling, operators would need state authorization and could face injunctions, penalties or exclusion from the market.
Kalshi cases created the legal template
Much of the current dispute traces to Kalshi, the prediction market company at the center of multiple state and federal cases. Utah, which bans gambling under its constitution, sued Kalshi and affiliated entities, alleging the company’s sports, election, politics and culture contracts violated state law. The CFTC then sued Utah and its attorney general, arguing the state could not investigate or enforce gambling laws against activity on CFTC-regulated exchanges.
That case, covered in the CFTC’s lawsuit challenging Utah’s Kalshi enforcement action, illustrates the stakes. Utah sought to block the contracts and recover up to $61.2 million. The CFTC said the state’s position would shut down prediction markets across broad categories and interfere with federal authority. A federal district court had earlier ruled in Utah’s favor in a related Kalshi case, and Kalshi appealed to the 10th Circuit.
Appellate courts have not spoken with one voice. According to prior litigation summaries, the Ninth and Sixth circuits have sided with state regulators in related Kalshi disputes, while the Third Circuit sided with Kalshi. That split has increased the likelihood that the Supreme Court may eventually be asked to resolve whether sports-linked event contracts can be offered under federal derivatives oversight or must yield to state gambling laws.
The dispute also has drawn intervention from former policymakers. Former CFTC Chairman Gary Gensler argued in a Supreme Court brief that the Dodd-Frank Act did not give the agency authority to regulate sports betting through its swaps jurisdiction. Former Sen. Chris Dodd, a co-author of the law, filed a separate brief supporting the states’ position. Their involvement undercuts any claim that the statutory question is settled.
New York raised the confrontation level
The CFTC’s position became more aggressive after New York Attorney General Letitia James sued Kalshi, alleging it was operating an illegal gambling business and seeking a temporary restraining order, restitution and civil penalties. The CFTC used emergency authority to direct Kalshi to continue operating in New York, saying the company had warned of a market emergency if the state action succeeded.
That intervention, described in the CFTC’s emergency order allowing Kalshi to keep operating in New York, was a significant step. Rather than simply argue federal preemption in court, the agency instructed a regulated entity to keep trading despite state efforts to halt the activity. Selig said Congress did not intend derivatives exchanges to operate under a patchwork of state gambling laws, and he described the products as financial instruments traded across state lines.
For state officials, the New York case sharpened concerns about consumer protections. James argued prediction markets expose residents, including younger users, to financial risks while bypassing gambling rules designed to address underage betting and gambling addiction. She also alleged Kalshi failed to pay applicable taxes. Those are the same categories of harm states frequently cite when pursuing offshore sportsbooks, sweepstakes casinos and unlicensed gambling sites.
The emergency order also changed the tone of the debate. If the CFTC can use emergency powers to preserve trading while litigation proceeds, state injunctions may become less effective. If courts reject that authority, the agency’s campaign to protect prediction markets could suffer a major setback.
Tribal and state regulators see broader risk
The CFTC’s emergency posture has drawn criticism from tribal gaming lawyers and other gambling-law specialists who argue the agency is straining its authority. In response to the New York order, attorneys questioned whether a federal regulator can direct a company to disregard state court action while appellate litigation remains unresolved. The criticism was captured in tribal gaming attorneys’ objections to the CFTC’s Kalshi emergency order.
The tribal gaming concern is partly institutional. Tribal and commercial gaming systems depend on licensing, compact compliance, suitability standards and regulator control over who may offer wagering products. If companies can characterize sports event contracts as derivatives and avoid those systems, tribal operators and state licensees could face competition from platforms that do not meet the same obligations. That includes tax payments, responsible gambling funding, licensing investigations and restrictions on product design.
The concern also extends to future suitability. Lawyers have warned that companies defying state orders or operating in contested markets may later face problems when seeking conventional sports betting licenses. State regulators regularly consider past compliance, integrity and respect for legal process when assessing suitability. A prediction market strategy built on federal preemption could therefore carry long-term licensing costs if courts side with the states.
Consumer protection pressure adds momentum
Louisiana’s gambling-policy environment is also being shaped by litigation against licensed sports betting companies. A proposed class action filed in Orleans Parish accused FanDuel and DraftKings of designing mobile apps to exploit addictive behavior, naming state-licensed casino partners alongside the operators. The plaintiffs alleged the apps used product features such as micro-wagering, timed bonus bets and limit-override screens to drive harmful betting.
The claims, outlined in the Louisiana class action over allegedly addictive sports betting app design, underscore why state officials are focused on gambling harms even inside the licensed market. If regulated operators face scrutiny over app design and addiction risks, unlicensed or federally regulated prediction platforms offering event contracts tied to sports and other outcomes are likely to attract similar attention.
That creates the backdrop for Louisiana’s clash with the CFTC. The state is not merely contesting a technical boundary between swaps and wagers. It is defending its ability to decide which companies may offer betting-like products to residents, how those companies are supervised and what remedies are available when officials see consumer risk. The CFTC, meanwhile, is trying to prevent state-by-state enforcement from narrowing or dismantling markets it views as federally protected.
The outcome could determine whether prediction markets expand as national financial exchanges or are forced into the same fragmented licensing map that governs sports betting. Louisiana is now one of the central venues for that fight.









