Nine US senators urge CFTC to reverse prediction market geofencing ban
Nine Democratic US senators have called on Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) Chairman Michael Selig to withdraw the agency’s recent interpretation barring prediction markets from geofencing or freeze its implementation until ongoing litigation is resolved.
The 5 November interpretation gives designated contract markets 30 days to end access restrictions based on a user’s location, which the senators say effectively requires prediction markets to offer contracts in all 50 states and on tribal lands.
CiG sister publication CDC Gaming highlighted the senators’ quote from a letter led by Adam Schiff of California, which stated: “Your unilateral decision directly conflicts with active court orders, undermines state and tribal law, and must be reversed.”
The letter notes that courts have ordered platforms to stop offering certain contracts in Michigan, Nevada and Washington, as well as on the lands of two California tribes.
The senators added that the CFTC’s move came hours after a federal court in California ordered Kalshi to geofence around tribal lands, which “raises concerns that the Commission may be coordinating with platforms currently engaged in litigation and encouraging them to violate state and tribal gaming laws.”
They also asked the CFTC to preserve all related records and communications dating back to 1 January 2025, and to confirm it is doing so by 23 November.
Selig told CNBC that the CFTC would take the fight to the US Supreme Court “if this is where it’s going.”
The CFTC last week sued Louisiana over a state court order blocking prediction markets, while a new American Gaming Association survey found 82% of Americans believe prediction markets should be regulated as gambling products.
Dig Deeper
The Backstory
A federal-versus-local fight moves to the center
The latest clash over prediction markets is less about one agency memo than a widening test of who controls gambling in the United States. The Commodity Futures Trading Commission’s Nov. 5 interpretation told designated contract markets to stop limiting access based on geography within 30 days or explain why they could not comply. That position would push federally regulated prediction market platforms toward national availability, even where states or tribes have gone to court to block sports event contracts they view as illegal gambling.
The backlash from Senate Democrats reflects how quickly the issue has moved from a niche derivatives dispute into a broader political fight involving state sovereignty, tribal gaming rights and the future shape of online wagering. Their demand that CFTC Chairman Michael Selig reverse course or pause implementation came after courts in Michigan, Nevada and Washington, as well as tribal plaintiffs in California, secured orders requiring platforms to restrict access in certain jurisdictions. The senators argue the CFTC’s interpretation risks turning a federal commodities regulator into a shield for products that local gambling regulators have not approved.
The agency’s position rests on the idea that derivatives markets need uniform national access under the Commodity Exchange Act. Critics say that principle cannot simply erase the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act, tribal ordinances or state gambling laws. That tension is now driving litigation on several fronts and has raised the prospect that the Supreme Court may ultimately decide whether sports-linked event contracts are financial instruments, gambling products or both.
The CFTC’s geofencing order escalated an existing conflict
The Nov. 5 directive was a clear inflection point. In its order requiring prediction markets to remove geographic restrictions, the CFTC said contract markets must provide impartial access and should not block users because of state residence or location. The agency also raised operational concerns, saying a customer traveling between states could lose access to positions, miss margin calls or face forced liquidation.
That logic may fit conventional derivatives trading, but it collides with gambling enforcement. Prediction market operators have increasingly offered contracts tied to sports outcomes, including football, basketball and baseball. State regulators and tribal governments say those contracts function like sports betting, even if they are packaged as event contracts traded on federally regulated exchanges.
The CFTC’s interpretation came at a moment when several companies had already chosen caution. Some operators, including DraftKings, Fanatics and FanDuel, voluntarily withheld sports event contracts in states where they held sports betting licenses, wary that gaming regulators could treat prediction markets as a compliance threat. Regulators in states including Ohio and Massachusetts had warned of possible licensing consequences. The CFTC’s 30-day demand effectively forced platforms to choose between federal market-access expectations and state or tribal gaming restrictions.
That is why the Senate letter framed the interpretation as more than administrative guidance. If implemented broadly, it could undermine court-ordered geofencing and pressure operators to reopen access in places where judges or regulators have told them to stay out. The senators’ request that the CFTC preserve communications dating to Jan. 1 signals they are also probing whether the agency coordinated with platforms during active litigation.
Tribes warned early that prediction markets threatened sovereignty
Tribal governments have been among the most forceful opponents of sports prediction markets because the products sit near the core of tribal gaming exclusivity. Under IGRA and tribal-state compacts, many tribes have negotiated rights over casino gaming and, in some states, sports betting. Prediction markets threaten to bypass those arrangements by using federal commodities law rather than gaming law as the governing framework.
The Indian Gaming Association had already elevated the issue before the CFTC’s latest move. At a September conference, the group’s chairman warned that prediction markets were “not simply a debate over a new financial product” and said they could become a pathway around tribal sovereignty, IGRA, tribal-state compacts and established gaming laws. The IGA said it was pursuing litigation, congressional advocacy, regulatory engagement and work with states, commercial gaming interests and consumer protection advocates. It also said it was examining tribal regulatory notices, cease-and-desist actions and other exercises of tribal authority. That effort was detailed in the association’s renewed warning about prediction markets and tribal regulation.
The tribal concern extends beyond sports. If a federally regulated exchange can list contracts tied to game outcomes over state and tribal objections, tribal leaders worry similar logic could be applied to products resembling casino games. That would weaken a regulatory structure built over decades, one that supports tribal government services, employment and economic development.
The Senate letter’s references to tribal lands and tribal law show that argument has gained political traction. The senators are not only defending state regulators. They are also aligning with tribes that see the CFTC’s approach as a direct challenge to self-government.
Kalshi’s court battles made the abstract dispute concrete
Kalshi has become the central test case because it argues its sports event contracts are federally regulated swaps under the Commodity Exchange Act, while states and tribes say the contracts are illegal gaming. A major development came when a federal judge barred Kalshi from offering certain sports event contracts on the lands of the Blue Lake Rancheria and the Chicken Ranch Rancheria of Me-Wuk Indians in California. The first tribal injunction against Kalshi over California sports contracts applied to football, basketball, baseball, soccer, tennis and UFC contracts.
That ruling gave tribes a concrete legal win and sharpened the timing problem for the CFTC. The agency issued its geofencing interpretation shortly after the California order, leading senators to argue the commission was effectively encouraging platforms to violate tribal gaming laws or court directives. The California dispute also undercut the idea that jurisdictional objections are theoretical. Courts have already found enough merit in some claims to restrict access.
Kalshi’s position is that exclusive CFTC jurisdiction preempts state and tribal restrictions. Its opponents counter that the Commodity Exchange Act does not grant a license to conduct gaming on tribal lands or in states where sports betting is prohibited or tightly licensed. That unresolved question is driving parallel lawsuits and creating uncertainty for platforms, regulators and potential investors.
The litigation has spread beyond tribal land. State authorities have brought or threatened actions against prediction market platforms, and the CFTC has responded by suing some states over attempts to enforce gambling laws. Each new case raises the stakes because inconsistent rulings could produce a patchwork of access rules, the very result the CFTC says national markets cannot tolerate.
Democrats have shifted from product bans to budget pressure
Congressional Democrats have pursued multiple strategies as prediction markets expanded. Earlier proposals sought to ban specific event contracts tied to sports, elections and government actions. More recently, senators have focused on the CFTC’s litigation posture and the use of federal funds. In a separate push, Richard Blumenthal, Jeff Merkley and other Democrats asked appropriators to stop the agency from using federal money to challenge state and tribal enforcement actions. Their effort to block CFTC funding for prediction market cases framed the agency’s lawsuits as a campaign that could help online prediction markets bypass consumer protections.
That budget strategy is narrower than an outright ban but potentially powerful. If Congress restricts funding, the CFTC could be limited in its ability to sue states or tribes seeking to enforce gambling laws. It would also signal that lawmakers do not accept the agency’s expansive view of federal preemption in this area.
The latest Senate letter builds on that approach but targets the Nov. 5 interpretation directly. By asking Selig to reverse the interpretation or freeze it until litigation is resolved, the senators are trying to prevent the CFTC from creating facts on the ground before courts settle the underlying legal question. Their request to preserve records suggests oversight hearings or further congressional action could follow.
California’s experience shows why tribes still hold leverage
The broader online betting industry is watching because prediction markets could disrupt carefully negotiated state and tribal models. California is the clearest example. After DraftKings and FanDuel backed a costly 2022 online sports betting ballot effort that tribes opposed, both measures failed decisively. The companies have since changed tone, acknowledging mistakes and emphasizing tribal-led expansion. At the Indian Gaming Association’s annual convention, their executives said they would not pursue another adversarial ballot measure and instead would seek tribal partnerships. That reset was described in the account of how FanDuel and DraftKings sought peace with California tribes over sports betting expansion.
That history matters because it shows the political cost of bypassing tribes in a major gaming market. Commercial operators that need state gaming licenses have incentives to avoid antagonizing regulators and tribal governments. Prediction market platforms, by contrast, argue they can operate nationally under federal commodities law. If that argument prevails, it could give them a route around the compromises that have governed sports betting legalization since 2018.
For states, tribes and licensed sportsbooks, the stakes are regulatory as well as commercial. A ruling that broadly favors prediction markets could weaken state licensing systems, compact revenue and responsible gambling controls. A ruling against them could confine sports event contracts to jurisdictions willing to authorize them as gambling or force exchanges to abandon the products. The Senate intervention is therefore part of a larger struggle over whether the next phase of online wagering will be built through state and tribal consent or federal market access.









