AGA survey: 82% of Americans think prediction markets should be regulated as gambling products

17 November 2026 at 2:51am UTC-5
Email, LinkedIn, and more

A new survey by the American Gaming Association (AGA) indicates that 82% of respondents believe that prediction markets “should be regulated like gambling products, not financial products.”

Prediction markets are currently overseen by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC), which claims exclusive jurisdiction over them, while a growing number of states argue that sports event contracts constitute gambling. The hotly debated issue may ultimately be resolved by the US Supreme Court.

Article continues below ad
PayNearMe

The survey, published on Monday, found 84% of surveyed Democrats were in favor of gambling regulation for prediction markets, falling to 82% for Republicans and 80% for independents.

The survey also found that half of respondents wrongly believe prediction markets are licensed by state gaming regulators, while noting that “Americans see ‘prediction market’ betting as financially risky as casino and sports betting, and far riskier than a stock or a mortgage.”

Investing in cryptocurrency was ranked as having the same risk as placing a bet on a prediction market, with casino games and sports bets rated slightly lower, and investing in the stock market rated significantly lower.

Article continues below ad
GLI email

Despite the caution regarding prediction markets, respondents continue to embrace legal gaming, with “88% saying gambling is acceptable entertainment and a majority (52%) gambling in the past year.”

Across the gambling types surveyed, igaming, sports betting and physical casino gaming all saw lower participation in 2026 than in 2025, with participation in both igaming and sports betting falling below 20%, while physical casino gaming, despite also declining, remained above 25%.

AGA President and CEO Bill Miller criticized prediction markets’ sports event contracts, saying, “Insidiously misrepresenting sports betting as an investment to 18-year-olds, and telling them it can pay their rent or college tuition, is a grotesque business practice that undermines decades of work industry, state, and tribal regulators have done to protect and educate consumers.”

Article continues below ad

The executive added: “Across party lines, Americans and 47 attorneys general agree that ‘prediction markets’ should be subject to the same rules and provide the same regulatory oversight and consumer protections as state-and-tribal-licensed sportsbooks.”

Miller also reinforced the role of gaming in US society, noting “Americans continue to embrace legal gaming as mainstream entertainment and value the tourism, jobs, and critical tax revenue our industry delivers to communities across the country.”

The survey was conducted online between 2 and 18 September this year, with a sample of 2,268 registered voters aged 21 and older and a margin of error of plus or minus 2%.

CiG Insignia
Locations:
Verticals:
Sectors:

Dig Deeper

The Backstory

Public opinion hardens around a regulatory divide

The American Gaming Association’s latest survey lands at a pivotal moment for prediction markets, which have moved from a niche financial-market product into a direct challenge to the state-by-state sports betting system built after the fall of the federal wagering ban. The survey’s finding that 82% of Americans think prediction markets should be regulated as gambling products rather than financial products gives the casino industry a consumer-facing argument in a dispute that has been driven largely by regulators, courts, operators and trade groups.

The AGA has been laying the groundwork for that argument for months. An earlier YouGov poll commissioned by the trade group found that about 80% of Americans wanted sports event contracts regulated like other forms of sports betting, with oversight by state and tribal gaming regulators rather than the Commodity Futures Trading Commission. That research, reported in a prior AGA survey on public attitudes toward prediction markets, also found that 70% of Americans believed prediction platforms offering sports contracts were exploiting loopholes to act as unlicensed sportsbooks.

The newest poll sharpens that message by framing prediction markets not only as a regulatory concern but as a consumer-risk issue. Respondents ranked prediction-market betting as roughly as risky as cryptocurrency and riskier than traditional stock investing. That matters because prediction-market operators frequently describe their products as trading, not betting. The AGA is seeking to collapse that distinction in the public mind, arguing that the same activity should not be treated differently simply because it is routed through a federally regulated exchange rather than a licensed sportsbook.

How sports contracts became the flashpoint

Prediction markets have long operated under CFTC oversight, allowing users to trade contracts tied to future outcomes. The political and regulatory fight escalated when sports event contracts began to look functionally similar to wagers already offered by sportsbooks. States argue that if a customer can risk money on the outcome of a game, player performance or sports event, the product falls within gambling law. Prediction-market firms contend they are offering event contracts under federal commodities law.

That jurisdictional conflict has created a rare split between federal market regulation and state gambling authority. The CFTC has claimed exclusive jurisdiction over federally listed contracts, while a growing group of states says sports event contracts intrude on licensing systems that were created to control access, collect tax revenue and enforce consumer-protection rules. The stakes are especially high because sports betting remains illegal or limited in several large states, including California and Texas. A prediction-market model could reach customers in those states without waiting for lawmakers or voters to approve online sportsbooks.

The casino industry’s concern is not limited to competitive pressure. In July, the AGA and Indian Gaming Association urged Congress to ban sports event contracts ahead of a House Agriculture subcommittee hearing examining market integrity and customer protections. As described in the industry groups’ push for a congressional ban on sports event contracts, the AGA and IGA argued that sports contracts bypass state and tribal law, weakening systems that fund public services, tribal governments and local economic programs. The groups also said prediction markets undercut licensed operators that must comply with state-by-state tax rates, advertising rules and responsible-gambling mandates.

Sports betting’s growth makes the fight more consequential

The dispute is unfolding as online sports betting becomes a more embedded part of US consumer behavior. A Siena Research Institute survey found that 27% of Americans had an active online sports betting account, up from about 22% in 2025 and 19% in 2024. The trend, covered in Siena research showing more than a quarter of Americans have online sportsbook accounts, shows why regulators are sensitive to products that could expand betting-like activity outside the existing framework.

The same data pointed to the dual nature of the market. Most bettors said they gambled for entertainment and to make sports more exciting, but many also reported behavior linked to financial risk, including chasing losses and regretting wagers. Those findings reinforce the AGA’s argument that sports contracts should carry the same protections as licensed betting, including age controls, self-exclusion tools, geolocation, limits on funding and state oversight of marketing.

Sportsbooks also have spent years shifting customers toward higher-frequency betting. Proposition wagers, parlays and in-play markets have become central to handle growth. A Jefferies survey found strong interest in those products, with 80% of surveyed bettors saying they had tried prop bets and 90% saying they were engaged with in-play activities. The findings, detailed in Jefferies analysis on in-play betting and prop-bet demand, help explain why prediction markets focused on sports are so sensitive for incumbent operators: They target the same consumer appetite that is driving sportsbook economics.

Operators split from the trade group’s position

The politics became more complicated when major sportsbook operators began moving toward prediction markets themselves. DraftKings and FanDuel have been among the biggest beneficiaries of state-regulated sports betting, but both have explored federally regulated event-contract products as a way to reach more states and create new revenue lines. That divergence exposed a strategic divide inside the industry.

DraftKings formalized the split by leaving the AGA before announcing its prediction-market product. Its launch, described in DraftKings’ rollout of a prediction market with CME Group, covered 38 states and the District of Columbia, including jurisdictions without legal online sports betting. The company said sports and financial markets would be available initially, with entertainment and culture categories expected later. It also said it would extend responsible-gaming principles into what it called responsible trading, including deposit limits, cool-off periods, self-exclusion and educational materials.

That approach highlights the industry’s strategic tension. The AGA is arguing that prediction markets should be treated as gambling because consumers experience them like gambling. DraftKings is betting that a federally supervised event-contract model can coexist with, and perhaps complement, its sportsbook business. For operators, the appeal is clear: a national or near-national product could soften dependence on new state legalizations, which have slowed, and reduce exposure to high sports-betting tax rates in some jurisdictions.

But the move also validates the fears of state regulators and tribal gaming interests. If major sportsbook brands can use a CFTC-regulated structure to offer sports-linked products where sportsbooks are not authorized, states may lose leverage over market entry, tax collection and consumer rules. That is why the debate has shifted from whether prediction markets are innovative to who gets to decide the terms of sports wagering access in the United States.

Courts, Congress and regulators face the next test

The AGA’s latest survey is designed to influence that next phase. Public opinion is not binding on the CFTC, Congress or courts, but it can help frame the issue as one of regulatory consistency rather than industry protectionism. The trade group is also emphasizing bipartisan agreement, noting similar views among Democrats, Republicans and independents. That gives lawmakers political cover if they choose to restrict sports event contracts or clarify that state gambling rules apply.

The legal question may ultimately turn on whether federal commodities law preempts state gambling authority when contracts are listed on regulated exchanges. If courts side with prediction-market operators, the result could create a parallel path for sports wagering outside the licensing structure states have spent years building. If states and gaming groups prevail, prediction platforms may be forced to exclude sports contracts, seek gambling licenses or limit products to non-sports categories.

For consumers, the practical issue is simpler: whether a sports contract marketed as trading carries the same protections and obligations as a wager placed with a sportsbook. The AGA’s survey suggests most Americans see little difference. That perception is now central to the industry’s case that prediction markets have outgrown their financial-market framing and should be brought under the gambling rules that govern the products they increasingly resemble.