New York sports bettors wager less, lose slightly more in January
Online sports betting in New York State faded slightly in January, down 1.5% to US$2.4 billion. But winnings by books were up 1.5%, achieving US$250.6 million, for a hold of 10.3%.
First in revenue, handle and hold percentage was FanDuel, which won US$113.7 million off US$875.3 million, for a 13% hold. DraftKings was second with US$79.7 million, US$818.3 million and 9.7% respectively.
BetMGM and Caesars Sportsbook vied for third place. BetMGM won US$13.4 million off US$242.4 million of handle. Caesars followed with US$11.5 million from US$160.7 million. BetMGM held 5.5%, though, to Caesars’ 7.2%.
Former ESPN Bet, now theScore Bet, made US$4.3 million from handle of US$54.1 million for an 8% hold. All other books held at 9.6%, realizing US$28 million from US$292.8 million of handle.
David McKee is an award-winning journalist who has three decades of experience covering the gaming industry.
Verticals:
Sectors:
Topics:
Dig Deeper
Related stories
The Backstory
Why a small slide in New York looms large
New York’s January betting figures show a subtle but telling shift. Handle slipped 1.5% to about $2.4 billion while hold edged up to 10.3%, lifting operator winnings to $250.6 million. FanDuel led revenue, handle and hold, with DraftKings close behind and BetMGM and Caesars vying for third. The mix suggests a maturing market where pricing power and parlay-heavy menus can support margins even when spending cools. That puts the onus on operators to balance promotions, product and risk to capture value without dulling volume at the start of a busy sports calendar.
The context matters. After several seasons of rapid adoption, U.S. betting growth is broadening beyond the earliest big states. Competitive pressure is rising, and player behavior is changing. New York’s incremental softness against firmer operator holds fits a national pattern of mixed signals: robust engagement in some months and markets, tougher comparisons and margin volatility in others.
A shifting map of demand
New York no longer carries the expansion story alone. This Super Bowl season, another large state is joining the fray. North Carolina will let residents place legal Super Bowl bets for the first time, with eight licensed platforms under the North Carolina Lottery Commission. The move broadens the Southeast’s regulated footprint and adds fresh customer acquisition ground for national brands like FanDuel, DraftKings, BetMGM and Caesars.
New access points can offset softness in legacy leaders, but they also change acquisition math. Operators typically spend heavily on promotions and media to stand up new markets, which can weigh on near-term profitability even as they chase scale. The balance between immediate revenue contribution and the cost to onboard and retain users will be tested as more states come online ahead of the next NFL season.
Meanwhile, recent state snapshots show that momentum can diverge month to month. In Arizona, November sports betting revenue fell 30% from October to $53.5 million despite an 8.6% rise in handle from September and a 22% year-over-year jump. DraftKings led wagers, FanDuel followed and smaller players gained incrementally. The split underscores how seasonal schedules, outcome variance and promotional cadence can pull in different directions across markets even when the broader trend line is up.
What the data says about U.S. bettors
Underlying consumer dynamics help explain New York’s margin resilience amid a light volume dip. U.S. players are spending more than global peers, according to Optimove’s US Gaming Pulse Report. The average deposit by U.S. players reached $604 in May 2025, up 10% year over year and well ahead of the 2% global increase. Average monthly sports betting spend was $1,001 versus $380 globally, and U.S. online casino outlays were more than six times the global average.
But the report flags softer engagement and retention in the U.S. than abroad. Players were active an average of 7.9 days a month versus 8.9 globally, and retention lagged the world average at 65% versus 71%. That gap pressures operators to lean on product innovation, targeted bonuses and same-game parlays to keep customers returning. In practice, that can lift hold — as New York’s January suggests — but it may also cap handle growth if casual bettors wager less frequently between marquee events.
For regulators and public stakeholders, the Optimove findings sharpen the trade-offs. Higher spend supports tax receipts and, for operators, cushions promotional costs. Lower retention raises questions about sustainable engagement and responsible play, reinforcing the role of education and safeguards as new states launch.
Operator strategies meet capital reality
Scale leaders are pivoting strategies to balance growth with profitability. FanDuel’s owner, Flutter Entertainment, reported a mixed second quarter: revenue rose 16% to $4.2 billion while profit fell 88% to $37 million, largely on a noncash charge. U.S. igaming revenue jumped 42% and sports betting winnings rose 11%, with $400 million in U.S. cash flow helped by favorable outcomes and extended NBA playoffs. International businesses also expanded, with acquisitions in Italy and Brazil integrated and igaming up 27% in the U.K. and Ireland.
The read-through for New York is that margin management, cross-sell to casino, and disciplined promo spend are central to maintaining cash generation when handle moderates. Leaders with diversified product sets and geographic mix can ride out monthly fluctuations in a single state. Smaller books may lean more on targeted niches, differentiated odds formats or lower-cost acquisition, especially where hold volatility and tax rates compress room for broad-based bonuses.
New York’s January leaderboard reflects that reality. FanDuel’s combination of parlay depth, pricing and product integration continues to drive a higher hold. DraftKings’ scale and data-driven promotions keep it within striking distance on handle and revenue. Mid-tier operators’ jockeying for third shows how thin differences in pricing, user experience and marketing can swing share in a mature market.
Policy crosscurrents and the growth runway
Legislative swings shape how quickly the market can expand beyond current strongholds. In the Southeast, North Carolina’s launch contrasts with Alabama’s latest setback. An Alabama bill to legalize online sports betting and a state lottery failed within a day of introduction, a reminder that consensus on gambling expansion remains fragile in parts of the country. The defeat delays any near-term entry into a new Southern market and keeps operators focused on adjacent states while advocates try to revive momentum in future sessions.
The uneven legislative map amplifies the stakes of performance in established markets like New York. When new-state catalysts slow, operators must extract more value from existing user bases, refine risk and boost product engagement to sustain revenue. That can raise holds — good for short-term results and state coffers — but also risks alienating price-sensitive bettors if lines widen or promos thin.
For policymakers, January’s New York outcome offers a prompt: healthy tax inflows can persist even as handle eases if responsible frameworks allow operators to compete on product rather than promos alone. As more states weigh entry, the examples set by early adopters will influence tax rates, licensing rules and expectations for consumer protections.
What to watch next
Three markers will determine whether New York’s January proves a blip or an early sign of normalization. First, Super Bowl and March Madness trends in new markets like North Carolina will show how fresh demand offsets softness in mature states. Second, operator commentary — such as Flutter’s guidance hikes alongside profit pressure — will indicate whether higher holds can coexist with disciplined promo spend at scale. Third, state-level volatility, as seen in Arizona’s November revenue swing, will test whether diversified product and risk controls can smooth month-to-month bumps.
For now, New York’s slight dip in handle paired with stronger holds captures a market settling into its next phase. Growth is broadening, consumer spend remains elevated and the policy map is uneven. The winners will be those that convert occasional bettors into repeat customers without overreliance on bonuses, manage volatility across states and deliver products that keep players engaged when the schedule turns quiet.
